With this in mind, the church of Christ is sometimes called, “legalistic.” The idea is that there is too much of an emphasis on keeping God’s law rather than grace and love. Some would say the church should focus more on “getting along” with other religions than emphasizing the importance of keeping God’s Law in worship, fellowship, and personal life. But, how can anyone expect to receive God’s blessings without being loyal to His commands? It is clear that God only blesses His people when they are obedient (Deu. 28:2; Rev. 22:14). It is also clear that the New Testament is a law (Rom. 8:2; Gal. 6:2; James 1:25). Therefore, when a person obeys the commands of the New Testament Law, that is when he will be blessed. If not, the eternal consequences of punishment will follow (John 12:48; Luke 12:43-48).
In the end, legalism is not looking to the Scriptures for authority and using the New Testament for doctrine and practice—that is simply “holding fast the faithful word” as God desires (Titus 1:9). However, if a person is making laws for God and acting as a modern day “Pharisee” then a true legalistic mindset has taken over (Mat. 23:23). A righteous person will see that God has a law to follow, under His grace, and carefully follow after Him in loving obedience (John 1:17; 14:15; Mat. 5:20; Rom. 6:14).
~Derrick Coble